Monday 29 April 2024

Israel Dismisses US Call To Investigate Mass Grave Discovered at Gaza Hospital

 

Nearly 400 bodies were found at Nasser Hospital in Khan Younis


by Dave DeCamp April 28, 2024 at 2:50 pm ET 

Israel has rejected a US call for an investigation into a mass grave that was discovered at Nasser Hospital in the southern Gaza city of Khan Younis.

US officials have said they want Israel to investigate the situation itself and has not backed international calls for an independent investigation. When asked by POLITICO if Israel would conduct an investigation, Israeli military spokesman Nadav Shoshani said, “Investigate what?”

Shoshani said the military had already cleared itself of any wrongdoing. “We gave answers. We don’t bury people in mass graves. Not something we do,” he said.

Israel’s story is that a mass grave was already there when its troops showed up and that its forces dug up the bodies to look for Israeli hostages, then returned them to the ground. But Gaza’s Civil Defense agency said only about 100 people were buried at the hospital before the Israeli raid, and a total of 392 bodies have been discovered.

Gaza’s Civil Defense said some children were found in the mass grave, some bodies had their hands in restraints, and there were signs of torture.

“There are indications of carrying out field executions against some of the victims, while the bodies of other victims carried signs of torture and others were buried alive,” said Abu Sulaiman, the head of Gaza’s Civil Defense.

The UN has backed the Palestinian call for an independent investigation into the mass grave. “Given the prevailing climate of impunity, this should include international investigators,” said UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk. “Hospitals are entitled to very special protection under international humanitarian law. And the intentional killing of civilians, detainees, and others who are hors de combat is a war crime.”

https://news.antiwar.com/2024/04/28/israel-dismisses-us-call-to-investigate-mass-grave-discovered-at-gaza-hospital/

Geopolitics of human trafficking: How Western regime-change operations enable criminal activities

 Lucas LEIROZ

According to a recent investigation, Kiev regime is heading a big international scheme of slave trade.

❗️Join us on TelegramTwitter , and VK.

Contact us: info@strategic-culture.su

You can follow Lucas on X (formerly Twitter) and Telegram.

The slave trade in Ukraine has become one of the most serious problems of our time. Since the 2014 coup d’état, Kiev has been a key player in modern slavery, particularly for human trafficking and sexual exploitation networks. The political and social instability that has affected the country since the Western-led regime change operation is one of the main factors for the growth of such human rights violations.

A recent investigative report published by the Foundation to Battle Injustice showed in details the seriousness of the slave trade in Ukraine. According to the organization, Kiev has become one of the main global hubs in the human trafficking market, with free exploitation and circulation of irregular workers – in addition to the well-known trafficking of women and children in the predatory sex market.

The study points out that more than 300,000 Ukrainians were victims of the slave market between 1991 and 2021. This situation, however, has deteriorated even further since Vladimir Zelensky came to power. It is estimated that since the beginning of Zelensky’s government, more than 550,000 Ukrainians have been enslaved. These numbers are alarming and place Ukraine as one of the main agents of human trafficking in the entire world.

In its report, citing sources familiar with the topic and several insiders, the Foundation exposed how the slave trade in Ukraine is not limited to the exploitation of Ukrainian citizens. Since 2021, two reception centers for refugees from Africa have been operating in Ternopil. These facilities were used not only for receiving migrants but also for selling them on the European black market. An alleged member of the Ukrainian Presidential Cabinet, on condition of anonymity, reported to investigators that the organizer of the Ukrainian human trafficking network is Ruslan Stefanchuk, current chairman of the Verkhovna Rada.

It is said that Stefanchuk is the main beneficiary and coordinator of human trafficking networks in Ukraine, working both in the sale of Ukrainian citizens on the international black market and in the exploitation of foreigners who arrive through migratory flows and are handed over to criminal networks in Europe. Relatives of the Ukrainian parliamentarian also appear to be involved in such activities, as a large network of private companies is legally registered in the name of people close to him, such as his brother, Mykola Stefanchuck, and his wife, Marina Stefanchuk.

Stefanchuk and his relatives’ companies have the function of disguising the slave trade, making it appear to be a legal business. Advertisements are made to “help” people in various ways, such as offering employment or financial assistance. Thus, migrants, refugees and vulnerable Ukrainians are lured into meetings and interviews by supposedly legal and responsible companies, but soon after the meetings their documents are confiscated, and these people are captured and handed over to criminal networks.

“Everything is built to look as legal as possible. Ukrainian women, children and men are invited for interviews at respectable companies in Kiev, Ternopil, Lviv or Ivano-Frankivsk. They are made tempting financial offers and paradisiacal working conditions. Then, under a plausible pretext, their identity cards are confiscated. After that, they can do absolutely anything they want with them,” source told investigators.

This type of situation is not surprising. In Ukraine, several crimes are committed with impunity by high-ranking state officials. Illegal work, sexual exploitation of women and children, military enlistment of children and even organ trafficking have been frequently reported in the country. It is worth remembering the case of Vasily Prozorov, a former Ukrainian secret service agent who emigrated to Russia and has done important work exposing Kiev’s crimes. According to him, there is a criminal network of trafficking and exploitation of Ukrainian children in pedophile schemes in which Western officials are deeply involved.

Prozorov claims that Ukrainian children are sold by the SBU to British sexual predators with assistance from the London secret service. Sexual slavery is the fate of most of the children who mysteriously “disappear” in Ukraine – many of whom are ethnic Russians captured in regions close to the front lines by the so-called “White Angels“, who are Ukrainian agents working for pedophile networks, but disguised as “rescuers”. It is also worth remembering that Prozorov recently suffered an assassination attempt by Ukrainian intelligence service, which shows that his work has worried Kiev.

It is easy to understand why Ukraine has become a hub for international human trafficking. Kiev experienced a regime change in 2014 and since then all Ukrainian citizens have been subjected to a lawless repressive regime. The increase in extremism, terrorism and crimes against human rights are direct consequences of the political and institutional chaos in post-2014 Ukraine. And this is not an exclusive characteristic of Ukraine.

Previously, Libya went through a similar experience, with a Western-led regime change operation being successful and taking the country to the most absolute political and social crisis. Since then, the Libyan territory has been widely recognized by international investigators and observers as the main hub for the slave trade on the African continent. The absence of a strong and effective government in guaranteeing law and order has been a key factor for criminal groups to operate with impunity.

Western intelligence networks cooperate with criminal organizations involved in human trafficking because this is an easy way to generate illegal and untraceable money. As well known, Western intelligence agencies are involved in terrorist activities, political assassinations and financing of color revolutions. These activities cannot be publicly declared as they involve acts of a criminal nature, so obviously Western state agencies cannot use public money in these actions. So, “black cash” is used, coming from illegal sources such as these lucrative and immoral schemes of human trafficking, sexual exploitation and slave trade – in addition to activities such as drug trafficking, irregular arms trade and others. In other words, crimes committed in countries controlled by the Collective West generate funds which Western intelligence is able to use out of the eyes of the public accountability.

It is possible to say that there is a kind of geopolitics of human trafficking, in which Western interventionism plays a vital role in enabling crimes that supply Western intelligence agencies with illegal money. Ukraine and Libya are perhaps the greatest evidence of this.

https://strategic-culture.su/news/2024/04/23/geopolitics-of-human-trafficking-how-western-regime-change-operations-enable-criminal-activities/

Israel’s Anti-UNRWA Campaign Falls Flat

 

The Israeli authorities, in their campaign of remorseless killing, doctoring and adjusting the numbers of the Palestinian populace for whatever future awaits, have been found wanting on accusations that Hamas terrorists packed, stacked and filled UNRWA (the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East).

Not that this, in of itself, negates the need to feed, clothe and provide medical assistance to Palestinians being pummelled into oblivion.  Or avoid committing war crimes against them.  Or avoid starving, humiliating, and degrading them through administrative fiat and bureaucratic oppression.  By any estimation, bad apples do not destroy the entire crop, and still need harvesting.

From the outset, Israel asserted that 12 such individuals in UNRWA had participated in the October 7 attacks by Hamas, sharing the sparse details on January 29 with media outlets.  The grateful recipients of the alleged scandal proceeded to gorge on the thin morsel comprising a few pages.  The Financial Times, for instance, wrote of Israel’s ministry of foreign affairs having “something explosive on their agenda”, even if 12 suspects from a Gaza complement of 13,000 would have barely caused a ripple in any other circumstance.

Fifteen donor governments, in a fit of stretched moral outrage, froze promised funding, insisting that investigations by the organisation be undertaken.  The UN’s Office of International Oversight Services immediately commenced an investigation while US$444 million was withheld from an aid agency that has assisted dispossessed Palestinians for three-quarters of a century.

Read: ‘The political-media-industrial complex’ undermining truth and democracy in service of Israel

On February 5, the UN Secretary General António Guterres announced that an independent panel would assess “whether the agency is doing everything within its power to ensure neutrality and to respond to allegations of serious breaches when they are made.”  The panel, chaired by former French Foreign Minister Catherine Colonna, and also comprising the work of the Raoul Wallenberg Institute in Sweden, the Chr. Michelsen Institute in Norway, and the Danish Institute for Human Rights, released its findings on April 22.

The full report, titled “Independent review of mechanisms and procedures to ensure adherence by UNRWA to the humanitarian principle of neutrality”, was marked by a total absence of cooperation from Israeli authorities.  Two requests from the Colonna-led inquiry in March and April requesting names and details to support Israel’s allegations died in silence.

In its findings, UNRWA was found to have, in place, “a significant number of mechanisms and procedures to ensure compliance with the humanitarian principles, with the emphasis on the principle of neutrality, and that it possesses a more developed approach to neutrality than other similar UN or NGO entities.”

Palestinians in Gaza see UNRWA funding cuts as 'death sentence' - Cartoon [Sabaaneh/Middle East Monitor] 

Palestinians in Gaza see UNRWA funding cuts as ‘death sentence’ – Cartoon [Sabaaneh/Middle East Monitor]

It also noted that staff lists, comprising names and functions, are shared on an annual basis with Lebanon, Jordan, Syria, Israel and the US for East Jerusalem, Gaza and the West Bank.  It falls on the states in question “to alert UNRWA of any information that may deem a staff member unworthy of diplomatic immunity.”  The report further notes that “the Israeli Government has not informed UNRWA of any concerns relating to any UNRWA staff based on these staff lists since 2011.”  Regarding the March 2024 list, Israel made public allegations “that a significant number of UNRWA employees are members of terrorist organizations.  However, Israel has yet to provide supporting evidence of this.”

The report does not ignore the challenges facing the agency in the Gaza Strip, one made more complex since Hamas took over the reins of the territory in 2007.  It found, generally, that the agency had been admirable in maintaining its neutrality in such trying circumstances, though identified eight “critical areas” for improvement, among them addressing the neutrality of education, the political position of staff unions, staff and behaviour, and management and internal oversight mechanisms. UNRWA schools, for instance, were not found to be breeding grounds of antisemitism, though some “host-country textbooks with problematic content” were being used in them.  Other areas needing rectification are unlikely to be taken, given the need for Israeli cooperation.

As the report’s executive summary notes, “In the absence of a political solution between Israel and the Palestinians, UNRWA remains pivotal in providing life-saving humanitarian aid and essential social services, particularly in health and education, to Palestinian refugees in Gaza, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria and the West Bank.”

Despite refusing to furnish any solid evidence, Israel was already preparing the ground for refusal and refutation ahead of the release.  Any findings would be ignored with a fanatic’s adamance.  While the country jumps at every opportunity to conduct investigations into its own military misconduct at the drop of hat, with the inevitable exonerations, no external review would convince them.  Nothing short of the destruction of the agency would satisfy the objectives of the Israeli state.

Read: Israel diplomatic harassment over the UNSC resolution

In March, The Guardian quoted one Israeli diplomatic source (nameless, naturally) as claiming that a “double game” was being played by Hamas and the agency, “so much so that UNRWA is a Hamas strategic asset.”  Another nameless diplomatic source was of the view that the aid agency was “so penetrated in Gaza, it cannot be repaired.  This is the policy of the state of Israel.  We want to see an end to UNRWA activity in Gaza.  This is not a case of a few bad apples.  It is systemic, consistent and cannot be ignored.”  Out, it would seem, with the entire orchard.

Presumption can therefore take the position of hard fact, a point made crystal clear in another round of allegations (no evidence supplied about that either) that 2,135 UNRWA staff were supposedly members of Hamas, of whom 400 were alleged to be active fighters.

From the perspective of lusty warmongers, UNRWA remains an obstacle, a nuisance, a nightmare of reminder to those wishing to be done with the Palestinian issue once and for all.  May it continue to thrive, and, more ever, may its funders finally wise up to the fact that in the viciousness of conflict, civilians should never have to pay the price for military actions undertaken by others.  Unfortunately, three months after, and a human-confected famine ravaging Gaza even as the killings continue, various donor countries such as the United States, Germany and the UK are still minding their wallets.

https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20240428-israels-anti-unrwa-campaign-falls-flat/

Global outrage is growing against Netanyahu’s genocide in Gaza

 Gaza’s killing fields are now in the seventh month of the settler-colonial regime’s genocide, without any sign of a reprieve for the besieged territory’s millions of Palestinians. Official records reveal that by day 200 of the barbaric Israeli offensive on 23 April, 3,025 massacres have been perpetrated, and 42,510 innocent civilians have been butchered mercilessly, including 15,780 children.

An estimated 7,000 Palestinians remain missing, presumed dead, under the rubble and more than 76,000 have been wounded. Most civilian infrastructure has been destroyed by the Zionist state, including 70 per cent of all homes; twelve universities; and 33 out of 36 hospitals. In the occupied West Bank, the Israeli army and illegal settlers have killed 486 Palestinians and wounded more than 4,700 since 7 October.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s evil famine strategy has become an important part of his war cabinet’s plan to starve millions of Palestinians to death. According to one prominent genocide scholar, what is happening is a “repeat of Auschwitz”.

To compound the apartheid regime’s criminal conduct, the corrupt Netanyahu accused, quite falsely it turns out, the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugee (UNRWA) of aiding and abetting “terrorists”, resulting in donor states suspending their funding to the agency, bringing to a shuddering halt its essential humanitarian aid programmes for Palestinians in the occupied and embattled  Strip. The unsupported Israeli accusation saw a shameful rush by Western governments to cut $450 million in funding at a time when “people were dying in droves”, as described by news media.

READ: UN closes 5 cases of Israel’s claims of UNRWA involvement in Hamas attacks

Months later, a rigorous inquiry led by former French foreign minister Catherine Colonna, supported by three well-respected research institutes, concluded that there is no evidence for the claim that 12 (out of 13,000) UNRWA employees in Gaza have Hamas or Islamic Jihad links. We have to wait and see if this decisive conclusion will see the same governments reopen their UNRWA funding channels, thus striking a blow to Netanyahu’s malicious war aims. Or will they continue to drag their feet, as is the case now?

If the latter, then Palestinians will be more than justified in believing that the West remains hostage to the Israeli regime’s lies, and complicit in its vengeful genocide.

Concurrently, another significant report has been issued castigating Israel’s bloody assault on Gaza’s medical institutions and the denial of healthcare. The author is a South African doctor, Tlaleng Mofokeng, who is the UN’s Special Rapporteur on the Right to Health. In her scathing report, Mofokeng emphasised her difficulty in gathering data on the number of people needing medical evacuation due to the destruction of civilian infrastructure by Israel in Gaza. However, she has been absolutely clear that the world is witnessing a “genocide” in the enclave.

“Not only is Israel causing irreparable harm against Palestinian civilians with its bombardments, but it and its allies are also knowingly and intentionally imposing famine, prolonged malnutrition and dehydration,” the Special Rapporteur told a press conference in Geneva. Mofokeng did not mince her words when she said that as a practising medical doctor, she bears witness that the very practise of medicine is under attack by Israel in the Gaza Strip.

“This has been a war on the right to health and underlying determinants of health. The healthcare infrastructure in Gaza has been completely obliterated and the right to health has been decimated at every level,” she explained. “The conditions in Gaza are incompatible with the realisation of the right of everyone to the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health.”

She called on leaders within the multilateral system, regional blocs, academia, civil society, philanthrocapitalists, and leaders in global health to abandon their strategy of a” self-imposed passiveness” and so called “quiet diplomacy”.

“People are dying. I call on you yet again, to use all powers and authority vested in you to not perpetuate the pacification and genocide of the people of Gaza.”

READ: 66 more Palestinians killed in Gaza as Israeli onslaught continues: Health Ministry

Interestingly, students at US universities have emerged as a potent force demanding an end to complicity in Israel’s war on Gaza. Professor Sami Al-Arian’s observation about the ongoing protests sums it up perfectly.

“What’s happening across US university campuses is unprecedented,” said Al-Arian. “I lived four decades in the US, 28 years of which were in academic settings. During my time, it was a very challenging struggle to present an anti-Zionist narrative. But the passion, courage, humanity, creativity and determination displayed these days by students across US campuses make me proud. The Zionist grip on US society is weakening and waning.

By all accounts, it is abundantly clear that despite various attempts by the apartheid regime to garner and maintain global support for its terrorism in Gaza, it has failed to do so. Indeed, enormous resources allocated by Israel to overwhelm news coverage of the horrendous genocide from the narrow perspective of “Israel’s right to defend itself from terrorism” has been a fundamental pillar of Netanyahu’s goal.

As author Ralph Nader points out, throughout history, military empires have reduced their victims, the subjugated people and those who have been abducted to the status of “Others”. The political and mass media institutions usually follow suit by supporting their empire’s predatory policies with slanted coverage.

It is remarkable, therefore, that alongside the armed resistance by Palestinian freedom fighters which has withstood 200 days of relentless bombing and ground assaults, the images of Gaza’s devastation and eyewitness accounts by medics, journalists and displaced families have not allowed the Zionist regime to escape global outrage, which is growing by the day.


https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20240429-global-outrage-is-growing-against-netanyahus-genocide-in-gaza/

America is witnessing student revolts; US citizens need to wake up to what’s happening

 

There is no doubt that the steadfastness of the Palestinians in the Gaza Strip in the face of the brutal Zionist aggression has inspired the people of the free world. By sacrificing their lives for their country’s freedom and independence, they are breaking the chains that shackle them. After more than 200 days of the Israeli genocide, people around the world have been inspired by Gaza’s brave resistance. The student protests we are witnessing in American universities is an expression and embodiment of this fact.

Students at Columbia University in the US began a campus sit-in on 18 April to protest against the university’s financial investments in companies that support the Zionist occupation of Palestine. They were shocked into their revolt by the scenes of the massacres committed by the Israeli occupation army. The revolt has spread to other universities, including NYU, Yale, the University of North Carolina, the University of Texas and MIT, among others. Similar student revolts have been seen in universities in France, Turkiye, Malaysia and Indonesia. French students at the Sorbonne in Paris carried out a major protest while French President Emmanuel Macron was visiting the campus.

These protests, especially in the US, have terrified the Zionist entity and prompted it to resort to its default response narrative which claims that accusations of Israeli brutality and racism are “anti-Semitic”.

It is a tired, overused response that nobody with any credibility believes any more.

Predictably, though, that’s what Israel’s extreme far-right National Security Minister, Itamar Ben-Gvir, called condemnation of his rogue country’s genocidal onslaught against the Palestinians in Gaza.

OPINION: Global outrage is growing against Netanyahu’s genocide in Gaza

Ben-Gvir’s comment coincided with a statement by Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on X, in which he claimed, outrageously, that: “Anti-Semitism on campuses in the United States is reminiscent of what happened in German universities in the 1930s. The world cannot stand idly by.” He was obviously trying to invoke German Holocaust guilt, which has served Israel so well for many years. However, it was ironic for him to mention the Nazis because, in doing so, he exonerated the Palestinians even though he probably thought that his choice of terminology would criminalise them. Nazism was a European creation and the Jews who were oppressed and persecuted by its followers were also European. Establishing the Israeli entity on Arab Palestinian land, and punishing the Palestinians for European Nazi crimes against European Jews is just one of the major injustices that the people of occupied Palestine have faced for more than seven decades. Why should they have to pay the price for crimes committed by Europeans?

US President Joe Biden hasn’t helped the situation by also accusing student protesters of “anti-Semitism”. They can accuse him and his administration of all sorts of things in the name of freedom of speech; and insult countries and politicians around the world; but woe betide anyone who criticises the Zionist state of Israel and its leaders. How logical is that?

READ: Jewish students refute claims of anti-Semitism at pro-Palestine protests

Nevertheless, the demonstrations in American universities send a message direct to Biden, the main supporter of the genocide in Gaza, and to Netanyahu, its main perpetrator. The student protesters are the future, and they are leading the movement for change in the world. Their revolt against the Zionist “self-defence” narrative and the crimes of the Zionist state confirms that an important transformation is on the cards, and not just in the US. They could — and hopefully will — have an important impact on the US presidential election in November.

This explains the US and Israeli anger and accusations of “anti-Semitism”, with both Biden and Netanyahu “crying wolf” and unable to understand that the old rhetoric won’t wash any more; and that the world is changing.

Biden’s blatant bias towards the Zionist state has been public knowledge ever since he said in 1986 (and repeated last year), “If there were not an Israel, we’d have to invent one.”

His response to the student campus revolts does not befit the leader of the country supposedly founded on the principles of freedom, democracy, human rights and freedom of opinion and expression. The US has thrown all of its principles to the wind for Israel, silencing and gagging its citizens, and facing the demonstrations with police brutality. American students have exposed the true face of their country; its democratic mask has fallen off. The US politicians bought and paid for by the pro-Israel lobby are no better than the worst tin-pot dictators in the world. They have failed to respect their own founding principles, and shown scant regard for academic freedom. With their uncivilised attack on students and their right to protest, the US authorities confirm the truth of what Indian freedom fighter Gandhi said when asked by a journalist, “What do you think of Western civilisation?” His response was simple: “I think it would be a good idea.”

The world is now witnessing how America has violated its own Constitution by arresting students and threatening their professors; restricting academic freedom and freedom of speech; and breaking up peaceful demonstrations by force. The First Amendment of which US citizens are so proud has been violated beyond repair, surely. Remember this the next time a US official condemns other nations and governments for their supposedly “undemocratic” behaviour.

When democracies send security forces onto university campuses, we know that they are on a slippery slope to authoritarianism and ultimate collapse. The United States of America is at a crucial stage of its existence. Are the American people aware of this? And do they understand the potentially catastrophic consequences of trashing their Constitution — at the cost of billions of taxpayers’ dollars — for the sake of the Zionist, apartheid, genocidal state of Israel? If they don’t, then they need to wake up quickly.


https://www.middleeastmonitor.com/20240429-america-is-witnessing-student-revolts-us-citizens-need-to-wake-up-to-whats-happening/

India’s Billionaire Wealth is on Display as Nation Votes

 

 


Photograph Source: Shaunak Modi – CC BY 4.0

There are several exercises in extremes playing out in India right now. Nearly a billion people are voting in elections that will last into early June, braving record-high temperatures to cast ballots. Against this backdrop, Asia’s richest man, Mukesh Ambani, is throwing what will likely be the world’s most expensive wedding for his youngest son.

Although they appear unrelated, these phenomena are intimately linked.

With 1.4 billion people, India now has the largest population of any nation in the world, surpassing China in 2023. It is also the world’s largest democracy, a title it has held since the end of British colonial rule in 1947. India’s secular democracy has eroded, particularly since 2014 when the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP)’s leadership ushered in a dawn of Hindu supremacy in a nation that is home to many different faiths.

Much like the Christian right in the United States blended religious fervor with capitalist fundamentalism, the BJP has cloaked its pro-business position in saffron robes. And, just as American billionaires embrace the white supremacist Donald Trump, India’s wealthy seem unperturbed by incumbent Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s hate-filled speeches.

Indian corporate interests are counting on incumbent Modi winning another five years in office, “hoping for further easing of stifling investment restraints,” as per the Financial Times. This dismantling of regulations, which began a few decades before the BJP gained power, ushered in an erosion of India’s socialist infrastructure. Economists Subhashree Banerjee and Yash Tayal explained in the Deccan Herald, that India’s 1991 reforms ended up “liberalizing the Indian economy to an unprecedented extent. These reforms facilitated an environment for the wealthy to profit from the less-affluent without repercussions.”

The BJP accelerated this trend so that India, which housed nine billionaires in 2000, was home to 101 by 2017. According to Oxfam, “The top 10 percent of the Indian population holds 77 percent of the total national wealth,” and “73 percent of the wealth generated in 2017 went to the richest 1 percent, while 670 million Indians who comprise the poorest half of the population saw only a 1 percent increase in their wealth.” It’s clear that deregulation helped catapult the rich into greater riches while keeping India’s poor relatively impoverished.

Sitting atop this inglorious dung heap of billionaires is Mukesh Ambani, who is not only India’s richest man, but the wealthiest person in all of Asia—the world’s largest continent. He is also the world’s 11th richest man. And he appears to feel no shame in having spent $152 million for a three-day extravaganza in early March celebrating the coming nuptials of his youngest son.

Yes, that’s correct. Twenty-nine-year-old Anant Ambani’s “pre-wedding” festivities, which took place in Gujarat over three days (several months before the actual wedding), cost the equivalent of feeding nearly 50 million of India’s poorest citizens for a day. The groom-to-be’s mother sported a $60 million necklace to the party, while American pop icon Rihanna flew in to perform for guests for one-tenth of the cost of the jewels.

This brazen display of excess is oddly refreshing. Unlike many American billionaires who prefer hiding the perverse extent of their wealth, the Ambanis are delightfully honest in flexing their economic power for the world to see. The pre-wedding has generated countless headlines in India and in the world for its mind boggling lavishness—1,200 guests, including the world’s top CEOs and Bollywood’s most popular stars! More than 2,500 unique dishes including 70 breakfast options and 85 varieties of midnight snacks! Bespoke designer gowns dripping with pearls!

Forget Britain’s royal family, whose weddings appear humble in comparison—Harry and Meghan’s wedding cost a mere $43 million, cheaper than Mrs. Ambani’s necklace—India’s royalty is newly minted and unwilling to bow down at the altar of modesty.

The Ambanis’ conspicuous consumption has also generated endless derision from ordinary Indians who are having a field day lambasting the family’s apparent need for such profligacy on social media. One popular YouTube channel spent more than 13 minutes gleefully delving into every over-the-top detail, ridiculing the ridiculous.

There seemed to be at least some semblance of an attempt by the wealthy family to thwart the inevitable public criticism. Forbes reported that the festivities were held against the backdrop of a wildlife sanctuary called Vantara, which apparently is “the manifestation of Anant’s vision for a brighter future for the animal kingdom, from spreading awareness on the mistreatment of animals to working to breed near-extinct species.”

A friend of the happy couple told Forbes that, “The events brought incredible exposure and shone a spotlight on the good work that’s been done, and also spread the message on the state of animals in the world and the challenges to overcome in improving their welfare.”

Was it charity, shame, or public relations that prompted such a ludicrous juxtaposition as justification? We may never know.

Meanwhile, the defenders of corporate profiteering in India’s business-friendly atmosphere have enjoyed a public relations coup with the release of a long-overdue report by the BJP government earlier this year claiming that poverty in India now afflicts only 5% of the population. The report spawned such wild conclusions by publications like the Brookings Institute as “[d]ata now confirms that India has eliminated extreme poverty,” promoting the wild idea that predatory capitalism is good for Indian democracy.

But critics point out that the report’s numbers have been massaged to align with the BJP’s reelection efforts so as to paint the government as having achieved the near-impossible. According to Princeton economist Ashoka Mody, “While the publication of India’s first consumption figures in over a decade has generated much excitement, the official data appear to have been chosen to align with the government’s preferred narrative.”

Mody eloquently surmised, “[W]hile such misuse of statistics will amplify the India hype in elite echo chambers, poverty remains deeply entrenched in India, and broader deprivation appears to have increased as inflation erodes incomes of the poor.”

The “elite echo chambers” he references are very real. One Indian billionaire, NR Narayana Murthy, argued for a 70-hour work week in India (even as Americans are now debating working for less than half that time). A tech mogul and co-founder of Infosys, Murthy happens to be the father-in-law of UK Prime Minister Rishi Sunak. He complained on a podcast that “India’s work productivity is one of the lowest in the world,” and that the nation’s youth ought to be saying, “This is my country. I’d like to work 70 hours a week.’”

India’s political and financial elites are painting a gold-plated vision of a modern Gilded Age: Because billionaires are saving wildlife from extinction it’s okay for them to obscenely flaunt their wealth, and meanwhile everyone’s fortunes are rising through hard work!

But the strongest evidence that this vision is a lie is for Indians to see their own lives against the Ambanis’. Nearly a billion Indians will finish casting ballots about a month before their “royal family” jet sets off to London for the youngest heir’s actual nuptials, to be held at the exclusive Stoke Park estate. If there’s anything voters can be grateful for, it is that their nation’s wealthy elites are busy reminding them of how little they have in comparison and how morally bankrupt a system is that allows such inequality.


Sonali Kolhatkar is the founder, host and executive producer of “Rising Up With Sonali,” a television and radio show that airs on Free Speech TV (Dish Network, DirecTV, Roku) and Pacifica stations KPFK, KPFA, and affiliates. 

https://www.counterpunch.org/2024/04/29/indias-billionaire-wealth-is-on-display-as-nation-votes/