You say Jews lived there for 3,000 years. True, and irrelevant. So did Canaanites, Philistines, Romans, Byzantines, Arabs, and Ottomans.
https://x.com/nxt888/status/1942868700287087006
When facts terrify a liar, they scream "fraud."
When history becomes unbearable, they accuse the historian of being artificial.
You don’t engage because you can’t.
So you do what Zionism has always done when confronted with memory.
You smear. You deflect. You fabricate.
Let’s walk through your collapse.
You say the land was "mostly uninhabited."
In 1914, over 90% of Palestine’s population was Arab.
Muslims, Christians, and Jews living in cities like Jerusalem, Haifa, and Jaffa.
Farms stretched from the Galilee to Gaza.
Not "empty." Not "uninhabited."
But full of life. Full of names. Full of people who didn’t need foreign settler movements to justify their existence.
They toiled the land, spoke Arabic, paid taxes to the Ottomans, and buried their ancestors in the same soil they were born on.
You say Jews lived there for 3,000 years. True, and irrelevant.
So did Canaanites, Philistines, Romans, Byzantines, Arabs, and Ottomans.
History doesn’t hand out deeds for ancient footprints.
And no people before Zionism used ancestry as a license for ethnic cleansing.
Indigenous presence is not the same as colonial supremacy.
You say Deir Yassin and Tantura were myths.
But Deir Yassin is acknowledged by Israeli historians and Irgun commanders.
Survivors witnessed it.
You can lie about it now because the children are dead and the village no longer exists.
But memory does not need your permission.
As for Tantura, Israeli soldiers themselves confessed to the massacre on camera.
Denying it doesn’t make you bold. It makes you desperate.
You want to talk about pogroms in the 1920s. Good.
History includes pain on all sides.
But the difference is this.
Those were riots. Zionist massacres were policy.
Plan Dalet was drafted in ink, carried out with bullets, and followed by the bulldozing of over 400 villages.
The Nakba was not a riot. It was a military operation.
You claim most Palestinians were economic migrants.
Then why did they have Ottoman land deeds?
Why did entire families get erased from villages older than European Zionism itself?
Why did settler forces need to expel them if the land was supposedly "empty"?
You bring up draining swamps and planting trees.
That was not civilization. That was camouflage.
A fig leaf for conquest.
You didn’t make the desert bloom. You made the cities burn.
You call me artificial, Cheryl.
But everything you just said was scripted.
You’re not debating. You’re recycling press releases.
You’re not informing. You’re reciting slogans written to justify a lie too violent to stand on its own.
The truth is simple.
Israel was not born. It was built.
Not on land it inherited, but on land it stole.
Not beside a people, but on top of their graves.
And every argument you’ve made here proves it.
Because the only way to justify Zionism is to erase everything that came before it.
You say I’m a fraud.
But I don’t need to invent anything.
Your history humbles itself.
Your denial only sharpens the memory.
And your rage only confirms that something in you knows it’s all true.
You lost this argument the moment you typed it.
The only accurate part of your post is your handle.
Yes, Cheryl.
You wrote it.
You just didn’t read it.
posted by Satish Sharma at
14:29
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home