Conquest becomes title deed. Genocide becomes documentation. And all of history collapses into a ledger of whoever killed last.
https://x.com/nxt888/status/1927390946351530073
You accuse me of fabrication, then proceed to rewrite 2,000 years of history with the confidence of someone who skimmed a Reddit thread and mistook it for a PhD.
You claim "it was Jewish land" because Rome occupied it?
Congratulations. You just admitted it was occupied.
And if occupation equals ownership, then Palestine belongs to the Ottomans, the British, and now… Israel?
That’s not history.
That’s imperial real estate logic.
By your own standard, no one owns anything but the last invader.
Conquest becomes title deed.
Genocide becomes documentation.
And all of history collapses into a ledger of whoever killed last.
You say Islamic civilizations "don’t count"?
Why? Because they weren’t white enough for your narrative?
Tell that to a thousand years of Arab poets, scholars, astronomers, mathematicians, physicians, and architects—who preserved and advanced human knowledge while Europe was still burning "witches" and bleeding people with leeches.
But thank you for revealing the real issue:
This isn’t about history. It’s about supremacy.
When Islamic scholars documented Palestine, it "doesn’t count."
When Crusaders scribbled Jerusalem on maps, suddenly it’s legitimate.
You’re not defending facts.
You’re defending who’s allowed to be human in your version of history.
You say "Syria-Palestine" wasn’t a country—correct.
It was a Roman province. Just like "Judea."
And yet no one demands that "Judea" be restored to the map.
Because this isn’t about geography.
It’s about erasure.
You say "Palestine" on British Mandate coins is made-up nonsense?
You could Google an image in three seconds. Here, I’ll save you the effort:
"Palestine" was printed in Arabic, English, and Hebrew on official coins, stamps, and passports between 1927 and 1948.
It was internationally recognized.
You just refuse to recognize it.
You admit legal documents used the name, then wave it away: "Well, it wasn’t a real country."
By that logic, no nation under imperial control ever existed.
India didn’t exist under the British.
Vietnam didn’t exist under the French.
Algeria was just "French Africa."
And Native American nations? Never real—until someone planted a flag?
Nothing exists in your worldview until empire approves of it.
What you’re defending isn’t history.
It’s the myth that only conquest grants legitimacy.
But here’s the truth:
Palestine existed in the mouths of its poets,
In the tears of its mothers,
In the olive groves bulldozed to build settlements,
And in every refugee who still carries a key.
You can sneer all you want.
But if Palestine never existed,
You wouldn’t have spent your whole comment trying to prove it didn’t.
Because no one tries this hard to bury a ghost,
Unless they’re afraid it still haunts the land.
posted by Satish Sharma at
15:08
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home