The Distorted Claims About the Viral Photo of a Man Carrying His Wife During the 1971 War

MEDIA

2 HOURS AGO

The image is being shared to bolster claims about the oppression of Hindus in Pakistan and Bangladesh.

Archit Mehta

An image of a man carrying a woman whose clothes are torn has gone viral on social media. According to the accompanying message, the photo is from late poet and author Dr Dharamvir Bharti’s book. The image is claimed to capture a scene from the 1971 India-Pakistan war where a husband is carrying his wife who was raped multiple times. The message ends with the claim that the photo depicts the oppression of Hindus in Pakistan and Bangladesh.

[Translated from ये तस्वीर डॉ धर्मवीर भारती जी की पुस्तक से ली गयी हैं, 1971 भारत पाकिस्तान युद्ध का हैं, जहाँ पति अपनी पत्नी की (लगातार बलात्कार की गयी )अस्मत बचा ना सका, लाश हो चुकी पत्नी को लेकर कहा जाये? यही तो पूरा पाकिस्तान 1947 से और 1971 के बाद से बांग्लादेश में हिन्दुओं]”

It is noteworthy that the image is being shared in the backdrop of the controversial Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA) which seeks to provide a path for non-Muslim migrants from Bangladesh, Pakistan and Afghanistan to apply for Indian citizenship.

Twitter user @ChaanchalMaurya posted (archive link) the viral image. It was retweeted over 5,000 times.

Similarly, many Facebook and Twitter users have shared this image.

Fact-Check

Alt News performed a reverse image search on Yandex and found a YouTube video which carried the viral image. According to the video uploaded by Gracie Rosado in October 2014, the viral image was clicked by photographer Mark Edwards.

Also read: Fake Tweet Portrays AAP MLA Amanatullah Khan Saying ‘Islam Will Win Across India’

After performing a keyword search, Alt News found the viral image on the website of Hard Rain Project, a charity founded by Edwards. The image was clicked by the photographer himself and it is described as, “Refugees from East Pakistan arriving in India during the Bangladesh war in 1971.

The book Body Horror: Photojournalism, Catastrophe and War by John Taylor also attributes Edwards for this image.

While speaking with the website Rare Historical Photos (RHP) in August 2014, Edwards said, “I took this profoundly disturbing picture of a man carrying his cholera-stricken wife during the Bangladesh war in 1971. Ten million people crossed the East Pakistan (Bangladesh) border into India to escape the horrors of this bloody war.”

As per several online sources, Bangladesh witnessed an outbreak of cholera in 1971.

Alt News reached out to Edwards over email for more details. He informed, “I don’t know if she died from cholera or not but there was absolutely no indication she was raped.”

The photograph is, therefore, circulating with baseless claims in the view of the recently-enacted Citizenship Amendment Act.

The article was originally published on Alt News. You can read it here.

https://thewire.in/media/viral-photo-1971-war